TRANSLATE THIS SITE

HOME  •  RECENT ISSUES  •  RESOURCES  •  NEWS  •  LINKS  •  SUBSCRIBE  •  ABOUT HAZARDS

PO BOX 199   SHEFFIELD   S1 4YL   ENGLAND         WWW.HAZARDS.ORG       

Back to Toilet breaks

ON THIS PAGE

Britain: Golden toilet bid to flush out breaks pay

Britain: Bus drivers relieved at more toilets

Britain: Company films toilets on the job

Britain: Bus workers demand respect and toilets

Britain: Give us toilets or prepare for a sitdown strike!

Britain: Free-to-pee win in women's toilet campaign

Britain: AA wrong on pee and tea breaks

USA: Ford in “incredibly stupid” toilet crackdown

Britain: No pee for parking attendant

Union outrage at Pee&O breaks ban

Bus driver fights for toilet breaks

Workers "forced to pay for toilet breaks"

Fired if you pee, fired if you don't

Bursting bus drivers told to wait and wee

Call centre stink over time off in loo

Supermarket cashiers can’t check out for loo breaks

Jaguar attacks toilet breaks

Guard secures workplace toilet breaks

Piss off

Personnel backing

Ship workers say no, no, no

Dirty business uncovered on site

Union no go on no go policy

Pregnant worker fired over toilet breaks

Firm docks workers wages for loo breaks

Pee is for organising

Safety watchdog sniffs out bad washrooms

TOILET BREAKS: CASE HISTORIES


Britain: Golden toilet bid to flush out breaks pay
An MP is backing a union campaign for paid toilet breaks at a Scottish meat firm supplying the supermarket chain Tesco. Workers at Brown Brothers in Kirkconnel are forced to take unpaid lavatory breaks - a policy that has been condemned by Labour MP Russell Brown and the union Unite as unacceptable.
Guidance on toilet breaksRisks 363
Hazards news, 5 July 2008

Britain: Workers make a stink over loo breaks
A meat company supplying Tesco has been accused of “Dickensian employment practices” by making workers clock off when they go the toilet. The union Unite is now calling on Tesco to intervene to stamp out the practise at Dumfriesshire-based Brown Brothers.
BBC News OnlineHazards magazine toilet breaks webpagesRisks 362
Hazards news, 28 June 2008

Britain: Bus drivers relieved at more toilets
Bus drivers are relieved authorities have agreed to speed-up the introduction of toilets along London's bus routes. Unite organiser, Peter Kavanagh, said “significant extra resource” had been agreed to combat what was “a very serious problem.”
This is local LondonTUC/Hazards toilet breaks campaign
Hazards news, 1 September 2007

Britain: Company films toilets on the job
The union UNITE has told a firm it must remove CCTV cameras after they were discovered filming workers in the factory's toilet blocks. ThyssenKrupp Automotive (TKA) Tallent Chassis, in Newton Aycliffe, County Durham, was accused of a “horrendous breach of employee privacy.”

Northern EchoHazards workplace privacy webpages and toilet breaks webpages
Hazards news, 25 August 2007

Britain: Bus workers demand respect and toilets
London’s bus workers took to the streets of the capital on 23 August to demand proper toilet facilities on bus routes and at their workplaces – and immediately won support from the mayor of London. The workers, members of Unite, are threatening a full strike ballot if Transport for London (TfL) and London’s local authorities don’t unblock planning obstacles and speed up action to provide facilities.
Unite news releaseBBC News Online

Britain: Give us toilets or prepare for a sitdown strike!
London's bus workers are to stage a series of protests at key London transport and local government offices on Thursday 23 August to protest at the lack of toilet facilities. The campaign has taken a new turn with the capital's bus workers, all members of the TGWU section of Unite, threatening a full strike ballot if Transport for London (TfL) and London's local authorities don't act.
Unite news releaseTUC/Hazards toilet breaks campaign
Hazards news, 4 August 2007

Britain: Free-to-pee win in women's toilet campaign
Women truck drivers who use the port of Folkestone are celebrating a breakthrough this week in their worldwide ‘Free to Pee’ campaign. Following pressure from transport union TGWU, the harbour master at the cross channel port has announced the opening of a women's toilet.
Risks 244, 18 February 2006

Britain: AA wrong on pee and tea breaks
Call centre workers employed by the car recovery giant AA say the firm must come clean on toilet and other breaks. Paul Maloney, GMB senior organiser said: Adults in the AA call centres have to put up their hands like schoolchildren to get time to get a drink of water or to visit the toilet.”
Risks 232, 12 November 2005

USA: Ford in “incredibly stupid” toilet crackdown
You know things are tense at work when management starts timing rest room breaks. But Ford Motor Co is doing just that.
Risks 231, 5 November 2005

Britain: No pee for parking attendant
A parking attendant has been suspended for going to the toilet. The GMB member, employed by APCOA and who works in Kensington and Chelsea, has been barred from work since 29 July and is facing disciplinary action.
Risks 220, 20 August 2005

Australia: Union outrage at Pee&O breaks ban
A UK-registered company which forced Australian call centre workers to carry a "pee pole" to signify they're going to the toilet has responded to staff protests by banning all breaks.
Risks 184, 27 November 2004

Britain
Bus driver fights for toilet breaks
An ex-bus driver whose health was ruined by the lack of toilets on bus routes, is taking his former employer to the European Court of Human Rights. Arthur Martin, who worked for First Bus, had to have surgery to remove half his prostate, a problem doctors say had been caused by being denied loo breaks for long periods.
Risks 149, 27 March 2004

Britain
Workers "forced to pay for toilet breaks"
Factory workers at TTems in Blyth have been told by bosses they will have to pay back wages for the time they spend on visits to the toilet and cigarette breaks.
Risks 147, 13 March 2004

USA
Fired if you pee, fired if you don't
Workers suffering from paruresis or shy bladder syndrome are being fired as a result. Drug test happy US employers a treating failure to provide a urine sample as a refusal to submit to a drug test.
Risks 143, 14 February 2004

Australia
Bursting bus drivers told to wait and wee

Bus drivers in Australia are piddling in bottles, buckets or at the road side because of a chronic lack of toilets.

Drivers in New South Wales say this is an industry wide problem and that operators and the government are failing to address a serious health issue.

Former bus driver and Transport Workers Union organiser Mick Pieri said: "The drivers have to hang on for hours on end. A lot of time when you need to go to the loo you have to go through passengers just to get to the toilet. The passengers can be irate because the bus is running late."

Pieri says the issue is about more than just toilets. "We need facilities with hot and cold running water, proper meal rooms, proper amenities."

He suspects that being forced to hold off going to the toilet on a regular basis could be linked to a high incidence of prostate problems among bus drivers.

TUC launched its own "gotta go!" campaign last year after Hazards magazine revealed UK workers were routinely being denied loo breaks and were at risk of a range of health problems as a result.

Risks 138, 10 January 2004

 

AUSTRALIA: Call centre stink over time off in loo

Employees at a company owned by Australia's second biggest telecoms company say their bosses have ordered them to record as "personal time" the amount of time they spend in the toilet. More than 60 workers at an RSL COM call centre are being forced to time themselves going to the toilet and make up the time at the end of the day or risk losing pay.

Members of the union CEPU have now started a "low key" campaign to end what they describe as harassment, excessive surveillance and monitoring over toilet breaks.

"We are disgusted by this over-the-top behaviour by management," said Alice Salomon, CEPU branch organiser.

"It is demeaning for grown adults to be treated like school kids and have to account for the time taken to go to the toilet…Managers are spending more time on monitoring toilet breaks than it actually takes to use the bathroom." She added the policy could force workers to forgo loo breaks, which could lead to serious health problems.

Workers OnlineRisks 120, 23 August 2003

 

Supermarket cashiers can’t check out for loo breaks

Supermarket cashiers in Argentina are being forced to wear nappies (diapers) because they can’t take toilet breaks at work, a union official said.

Female cashiers in western Mendoza province must wear adult nappies in case 'cold, nerves, pressure or stress' provoke incontinence, union official Jorge Cordova told local news agency Diarios y Noticias.

Cordova refused to name the supermarket, but he did say the chain is backed by foreign capital, said Sandra Varela, Mendoza's labour subsecretary. "The truth is, it's difficult to imagine a line of 20 adult cashiers wearing diapers for eight hours," said Varela, who is investigating the matter. "In 17 years as a labour lawyer, I've never heard anything like this before."

TUC has highlighted widespread loo breaks abuse in the UK, and is calling for a legal right for workers to take a toilet break. Earlier this year GMB member Gavin Ruddick won an employment tribunal after his employer said the security guard could not take any breaks during a 12-hour shift.

Risks 118, 9 August 2003

 

Jaguar attacks toilet breaks

Luxury car-maker Jaguar has come under fire from workers after slamming the lid on toilet breaks. Paint shop workers have told by personnel chiefs at the Castle Bromwich plant they should not go to the toilet during working time.

The loo breaks embargo started with a written briefing from the company’s Employee Relations Department, whose "bell-to-bell" edict says workers must seek permission from their supervisor if they need to leave the track for any reason.

The briefing warns that anyone failing to comply could end up facing disciplinary action. It says: "All employees should endeavour to deal with issues during their break times. This includes leaving to go to the toilet. Due to the continuing high absence trend, it is likely that there will be times when delays in releasing people to go to the toilet cannot be avoided."

One worker said: "We can’t believe this. People can’t go to the toilet by schedule and they are threatening disciplinary action if people need to go outside of break times."

Risks 115, 19 July 2003

 

BRITAIN
Guard secures workplace toilet breaks

A Tyneside security guard has won a "groundbreaking" victory after claiming his employer would not let him go to the toilet at work. GMB member Gavin Ruddick said Reliance Security Services Ltd told him he could not take any breaks during a 12-hour shift at an office block.

A Newcastle employment tribunal ruled that the security industry is not exempt from Working Time Regulations and while it is not subject to the law that requires workers to have a 20 minute rest break every six hours, it must do "the next best thing," such as allow a number of shorter rest periods or one longer period. It stated that if any company were to be as ridiculous as to prevent a security guard from going to the toilet, then it might be guilty of degrading and inhuman treatment under the Human Rights Act.

GMB’s Joan Hoggins said: "This is a great result for our members and this will now send a clear message that the security industry does not fall outside the Working Time Directive and they must treat their workers fairly or pay the price. I could not believe that when Gavin approached me, informing me that he was to do a 12 hour shift, he was denied the right of any form of rest breaks." A further hearing will decide compensation.

Risks 110, 14 June 2003

 

AUSTRALIA
The ultimate piss off

Wollongong workers on poverty-level wages are losing up to $5,000 (£2,000) for taking toilet breaks, according to the union representing staff at a Stellar call centre. Other employees claim they have lost their bonuses, worth up to $5000 a year, for using sick leave entitlements.

The bonuses are significant to workers earning only $25,000 ($10,000) a year thanks to non-negotiable contracts that have slashed base earnings from the $35,000 (£14,000) paid to Telstra employees before their jobs were outsourced.

Stellar is Australia's largest contract call centre operation, employing more than 2000 people around the country.

The workers' union, CPSU, has launched inspections of Stellar call centres at Wollongong, Hornsby, Adelaide and Robina into suspected breaches of the Workplace Relations Act, and says the workers have been conned into accepting the new contracts.

"We have information that his choice has not been provided," CPSU official Larissa Andelman says. "That these people have not even been told that they have a right to choose."

Andelman says the reported use of bonuses to dissuade people from using their sick leave is a major concern to members. Stellar call centres are understood to have an unusually high number of employees absent on stress leave. Andelman says that annual staff turnover rates are as high as 40 per cent in some of the company's call centres.

Workers Onliine, 2 May 2003

BRITAIN
This time it’s personnel

Personnel professionals are backing the union campaign for sensible toilet breaks at work.

Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development adviser Diane Sinclair commented: "It is inappropriate for people to have to request to go to the bathroom, unless the nature of the work is that a production line stops or there has to be cover for that person."

She added that employers could be opening themselves up to legal action if they prevent someone from using the toilet when they need to. "Allowing someone to go to the bathroom is a reasonable adjustment under the Disability Discrimination Act," she said, adding if a pregnant woman is only given restricted access, she could also take her employer to court on a discrimination claim.

TUC’s Owen Tudor commented that some employers go to greater lengths to monitor toilet trips than it can possibly be worth. "One person told me that in his workplace they had a man who sat by the toilet door with a stopwatch and timed people," he said. "He also used to hand out regulation amounts of toilet paper. That cannot conceivably have been economically worthwhile."

Risks 99, 29 March 2003

USA
Ship workers say no, no, no to a bottle of pee

Shipyard workers rushing to complete a US aircraft carrier by 28 March are raising a stink about a shortage of toilets. Union officials representing members working on the Ronald Reagan say some yard workers have resorted to urinating in the corners on the brand-new ship, or in cups, drink bottles and plastic bags.

The US Navy moved 2,500 sailors onto the ship in the autumn, slowing down the last-minute yard work and placing most of the restrooms off-limits to shipyard workers. "You're not going to pee in your pants, you're going to find some place to go to the bathroom," said Jim Scull, chair of the health and safety committee for the United Steelworkers of America's (USWA) Local 8888.

Arnold Outlaw, president of USWA Local 8888, said although the company may be meeting the letter of the law by having the bathrooms off the ship, it is sometimes difficult for workers - especially some older workers who need to take diuretics and those with other medical problems - to get off the ship in time: 'If you're working six decks down, it can take more than 10 minutes just to get off the ship,' Outlaw said. 'You don't always know when you're going to get the urge.'

The company, Northrop Grumman, refused to provide additional portable facilities, he said.

Risks 97, 15 March 2003

BRITAIN
Investigation uncovers dirty business on site

Contractors on a Leyton building site are breaking health and safety laws by not providing proper washroom facilities, an investigation by the Waltham Forest Guardian has shown. It says its special investigation into the site has revealed that no hot water is being provided to builders by the Inner London Group and the two loos are rarely useable, a breach of the Construction (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1996.

A tip-off to the newspaper from concerned staff led to the investigation, which found just two portable toilets for around 35 to 40 workers. One worker commented: "The portaloos are serviced once a week and they are OK for about two days before they become full and unusable."

Larry Fenttiman, of the Inner London Group, denied the company was in the wrong. However, a spokesperson for the HSE confirmed it had received a complaint and the company had been contacted, adding: "We are not satisfied with what we've been told so it is being contacted again. It will be told what it is legally expected to do. We will take it further if necessary and if it fails to comply with the inspectors it is a prosecutable offence."

Risks 96, 8 March 2003

 

USA
Union no go on no go policy

The union at bourbon maker Jim Beam has won a reversal of its policy of limiting bathroom breaks for workers at a Kentucky distillery (Risks 69).

The rules – and disciplinary measures used to enforce them - outraged workers, some of whom said they’d had to pee themselves or face disciplinary action - and drew a citation from the Labor Cabinet, the official enforcement agency, which called the policy illegal.

"I am really glad to hear that they've come to their senses," Jo Anne Kelley of the UFCW union said. Krystal Ditto, who was one violation away from being fired, expressed relief.

"Nobody should have to go to work with that kind of fear," she said.

Rich Reese, top boss at the company, said: "We've listened to the concerns of our employees and have changed our policy." He added: “We will work with the local union to find a mutually acceptable solution for managing breaks on the bottling-line."

WNBC News



AUSTRALIA
Pregnant worker fired over toilet breaks

The Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU) said workers employed by TeleTech, US-owned and one of the world's largest call centre companies, were owed thousands of dollars in unpaid wages and had also been bullied and dismissed for taking sick leave.

A pregnant woman had been dismissed for taking too many toilet breaks, while another was sacked because she was in hospital with pneumonia, says the union.

Risks 71, 14 September 2002
ACTU's Call Central campaign - the site includes safety guidance




BRITAIN
Firm docks workers wages for toilet breaks

Mean meat factory bosses are docking £1,000 a week from their workers' wages for the time they spend in the loo.

Almost 200 staff at the Brown Brothers' factory in Kirkconnell, Scotland have been issued with smart cards which deduct their pay for the time they're away from the factory floor.

One worker, who feared the sack if he gave his name, said: "We have to go through a turnstile and up a flight of stairs to the toilet in the canteen. One week they took an hour off me, which is £5.28. There are 190 workers here so the company is saving £1,000 a week in wages. The motto among the staff here is: 'Have a break - have a quick crap'."

George Hodge, regional organiser with the Transport and General Workers' Union (TGWU), said: "We have been campaigning constantly to persuade the company to abolish this practice but they have so far refused to budge. Brown Brothers are the only company I have heard of to operate such a policy."

Not getting to the loo when you need to can lead to serious health problems, research has shown.

Risks 88, 11 January 2003

 

BRITAIN
Pee is for organising

Advertising staff at Bristol United Press used to have to ask permission to use the toilet at work - until their union started a protest leafleting campaign.

GPMU South West branch organiser Gavin Brooks said: "We received a fantastic response to the leaflet and management have backed down over the issue."

He told GPMU Direct magazine the toilet breaks campaign was just the beginning of an organising drive at the company.

And he has told newspaper staff: "If it is possible for the union to solve a problem just by giving you a leaflet, imagine what you could do if you got your union recognised."

Pee is for organising, Hazards 80, October-December 2002, page 13. Hazards 80 full contents



BRITAIN
Safety watchdog sniffs out bad washrooms




Decent washing facilities are vital in preventing occupational dermatitis and are an absolute legal duty. Would you use these?


This sink is unusable and illustrates a basic lack of regard for the health and welfare of the construction workers on site
Above, welfare facilities uncovered in a 2002 UK construction sites safety blitz conducted by the
Health and Safety Executive
.



HAZARDS MAGAZINE   •  WORKERS' HEALTH INTERNATIONAL NEWS